There’s a New Search Sheriff in Town – And Google’s Feeling the Heat
Home  >  Blog  >  There’s a New Search Sheriff in Town – And Google’s Feeling the Heat

There’s a New Search Sheriff in Town – And Google’s Feeling the Heat

Posted on 10 June 2025
There’s a New Search Sheriff in Town – And Google’s Feeling the Heat

For years, Google has been the king of the digital jungle, dominating how customers find everything from a plumber to an accountant. But recently, something’s shifted. There’s a new wave of AI-powered search engines that don’t just point you in a direction, they do the digging and analysing for you.

If you haven’t yet experimented with tools like GPT-powered search or Perplexity, now’s the time to start paying attention. Because while Google still owns the lion’s share of search traffic, these intelligent newcomers are changing the rules of the game, and fast.

Why AI Search Engines Could Give Google a Run for Its Money

Let’s start with the big picture.

Traditional search engines (yes, Google we’re talking about you) are keyword-driven. You type in a few words, and you’re handed pages of links. You then do the hard work, clicking, comparing, sifting through reviews and ads, and hoping you land on something useful.

But AI search engines? They don’t just search - they answer.

Here’s why that’s powerful:

  • They summarise, not just index. Instead of scrolling through 10 tabs, you get a direct, well-explained response in one go.
  • They understand context. Ask a natural-sounding question like “What’s the best local dog groomer that takes walk-ins and does small breeds?” and AI will give you an actual answer, after researching, and analysing not only the sites but also reference sources and reviews for you.
  • They reduce research fatigue. For time-poor people (read: nearly every business owner and customer), the idea of skipping the comparison stage is deeply appealing.

So, what does this mean for local businesses?

It means how people find you will be shifting. And if you're not showing up in these new search engines, or worse, if you're not even aware of them, you’re at risk of becoming invisible to the next wave of customers.

So... Who (or What) Is Perplexity?

If Google is the encyclopaedia and GPT is the chatty genius in the corner, Perplexity AI is the best of both, blending live web search with conversational AI to give you answers that are not only smart but sourced.

Perplexity’s claim to fame is its ability to pull real-time information from the internet and combine it with top-tier language models like GPT-4o and Claude 4.0 Sonnet. That means it doesn’t just rely on what it’s been trained on, it searches live, synthesises what’s relevant, and gives you a direct answer with links to where the information came from. No fluff. No guessing. No "click-and-hope" browsing.

What Makes It Different?

  • Live, Source-Linked Answers: Instead of showing you 10 blue links (like Google), or giving you a generic AI guess (like some chatbots), Perplexity gives you a clear, accurate answer with citations. You can see exactly where the info came from.
  • Incredible Speed and Clarity: Ask a complex question, like which local solar installer offers rebates in your suburb - Perplexity will instantly research, then summarise the web and show you sourced recommendations.
  • Contextual Conversations: It remembers your previous questions in the same session, so your follow-ups feel natural, no need to rephrase every time.
  • Customised Search Control: You can even steer it to prioritise sources like Reddit, YouTube, or academic papers, making it a versatile tool for everything from quick checks to deep research.
  • Built for Trust: Unlike many AI tools that "guess with confidence," Perplexity is upfront when it can’t find an answer and avoids inventing facts. It’s like having a research assistant who isn’t afraid to say, “I’ll check that for you.”

So if you're a business owner who wants to know how your business stacks up against competitors, or how customers might be researching services in real-time now and the future, Perplexity is a tool worth knowing.

Comparison Table: Perplexity vs Google vs GBT (ChatGPT with Search) for "Best Blind Shop Near Me" Queries

Feature / Criteria

Perplexity AI

Google Search

GBT (ChatGPT with Search)

Primary Sourcing MethodReal-time web search; prioritises up-to-date, local, and authoritative sources; provides citations in answers 2356.Crawls and indexes billions of web pages; ranks results by SEO signals, relevance, and authority; lists links for user exploration 235.Uses web search APIs or plugins to fetch current data; blends web results with LLM-generated summaries; cites sources 68.

Local & Industry Domain Focus

Strong emphasis on local (.com.au, .gov.au, etc.) and region-specific sources; references industry-specific domains slightly more than Google 6.Also prioritises local domains for location-based searches; strong in mapping and business listings 6.Less local domain focus; depends on web search integration and may be less precise for hyperlocal queries 6.

Review & Ranking Signals

Considers online reviews, third-party rankings, and citations from trusted sites; less influenced by SEO manipulation 256.Heavily influenced by SEO: keywords, backlinks, content optimisation, and business profile completeness; reviews from Google Maps/Business 235.Relies on reviews and rankings found in search results, but may not weigh them as systematically as Google or Perplexity 68.

Result Format

Direct, concise answers with citations and summaries; minimal clutter; conversational interface 2357.List of links, business profiles, map packs, ads, and snippets; requires the user to click through for details 235.Conversational summary with cited sources; may provide lists or explanations depending on prompt 68.

Depth vs. Freshness

Prioritises fresh, up-to-date information; answers are concise but may lack depth for complex queries 235.Offers deeper, more comprehensive results; freshness depends on indexing and ranking; sometimes cluttered with ads 235.Can provide both summary and depth, but freshness depends on integration and may lag behind Perplexity for breaking info 6.

Personalisation

Minimal data collection; can personalise based on session context and prior queries 5.Highly personalized based on search history, location, and Google account data 5.Session-based personalisation; less persistent than Google 58.

How to Optimise for Ranking

  • Get featured in authoritative lists and review sites
  • Encourage detailed, positive reviews on trusted platforms
  • Ensure accurate, up-to-date business info
  • Build brand visibility and mentions in local media and forums 23569.
  • Optimise Google Business Profile
  • Use local SEO: keywords, reviews, backlinks
  • Ensure NAP (Name, Address, Phone) consistency
  • Encourage Google reviews
  • Build citations in local directories23510
  • Ensure business is mentioned in reputable online content
  • Get featured in lists and reviews that may be scraped by AI
  • Maintain accurate website info and schema markup69.

Strengths

  • Fast, direct, and up-to-date answers
  • Transparent citations
  • Less cluttered
  • Strong on local and authoritative sources 2356.
  • Comprehensive, deep results
  • Strong mapping and local business tools
  • Highly personalised
  • Largest index 235.
  • Conversational, flexible responses
  • Can summarise and explain
  • Cites sources
  • Integrates multiple data points 68.

Weaknesses

  • May miss depth/detail in complex queries
  • Newer, so less user familiarity
  • May not surface all options if not well-cited online 235.
  • Can be overwhelming/cluttered
  • Results influenced by SEO/ads
  • Requires more user effort to sift through links 235.
  • Local accuracy varies with integration
  • May miss hyperlocal or less-cited businesses
  • Sometimes less transparent in sourcing 68.

 

Key Insights for Your Business

  • Google remains dominant for deep, comprehensive local searches, but is cluttered and SEO-driven.
  • Perplexity is gaining traction for quick, trustworthy answers with transparent sourcing, especially for users who want direct recommendations without sifting through links.
  • GBT (ChatGPT with Search) is versatile and conversational, but may not always be as locally precise as Google or Perplexity.

To be visible across all platforms:

  • Optimise your Google Business Profile and encourage Google reviews.
  • Build your presence on other authoritative review sites and local directories.
  • Get featured in “best of” lists and ensure your business is cited in reputable, local, and industry-specific content.
  • Maintain accurate, up-to-date info everywhere online and encourage clients to leave detailed, positive reviews.

This multi-pronged approach ensures your business is well-positioned as AI-driven search engines like Perplexity and GBT become key competitors to Google in the local search landscape

What should you do next? Test out all three and ask them each for their suggestion on who they would recommend, in your industry, location and see the results.  Here is one example on Perplexity,

Final Thoughts

Search is changing and it’s happening quickly. With AI tools like Perplexity and other AI-powered platforms now part of the mix, it’s no longer just about ranking on Google. It’s about being visible, trusted, and easy to find wherever your customers are looking.

If you're not sure where to start, you're not alone. We’re already helping businesses navigate this shift, and we’d be happy to help you do the same.

Tracey VoyceAuthor:Tracey Voyce
About: With more than 30 years business management experience, Tracey Voyce is the CEO of Bloomtools. Tracey has owned and managed many businesses and spent several years training and motivating coaches at the world’s largest business coaching franchise.
Connect via:LinkedIn
Tags:NewsPromotionsSearch Engine MarketingSearch Engine Optimisation